The CFL announced on Thursday the 2023 Eastern and Western All-Stars as voted by the local voting members of the Football Reporters of Canada (FRC) in their respective division’s markets and the National Chapter, the division’s head coaches, and fans.
The Toronto Argonauts led the entire league with 14 players being selected, while the Winnipeg Blue Bombers had 11 players selected. In total, 42 Americans, 11 Canadians, and one Global player make up this year’s All-Star Teams. The Edmonton Elks did not have any players selected for the Western Division All-Stars.
The league’s All-Star team will be announced on November 8, 2023.
Eastern All-Stars
| Position | Player | Team |
| QB | Chad Kelly | Toronto Argonauts |
| RB | AJ Ouellette | Toronto Argonauts |
| WR | DaVaris Daniels | Toronto Argonauts |
| WR | Austin Mack | Montreal Alouettes |
| WR | Tim White | Hamilton Tiger-Cats |
| WR | Damonte Coxie | Toronto Argonauts |
| WR | Justin Hardy | Ottawa Redblacks |
| OL | Darius Ciraco | Toronto Argonauts |
| OL | Brandon Revenberg | Hamilton Tiger-Cats |
| OL | Ryan Hunter | Toronto Argonauts |
| OL | Dejon Allen | Toronto Argonauts |
| OL | Nick Callender | Montreal Alouettes |
| DE | Folarin Orimolade | Toronto Argonauts |
| DE | Bryce Carter | Ottawa Redblacks |
| DT | Casey Sayles | Hamilton Tiger-Cats |
| DT | Mustafa Johnson | Montreal Alouettes |
| LB | Wynton McManis | Toronto Argonauts |
| LB | Tyrice Beverette | Montreal Alouettes |
| DB | Adarius Pickett | Toronto Argonauts |
| DB | Qwan’tez Stiggers | Toronto Argonauts |
| DB | Brandin Dandridge | Ottawa Redblacks |
| DB | Robertson Daniel | Toronto Argonauts |
| DB | Wesley Sutton | Montreal Alouettes |
| DB | Marc-Antoine Dequoy | Montreal Alouettes |
| K | Boris Bede | Toronto Argonauts |
| P | Richie Leone | Ottawa Redblacks |
| ST | Jevon Leake | Toronto Argonauts |
Western All-Stars
| Position | Player | Team |
| QB | Zach Collaros | Winnipeg Blue Bombers |
| RB | Brady Oliveira | Winnipeg Blue Bombers |
| WR | Dalton Schoen | Winnipeg Blue Bombers |
| WR | Keon Hatcher | B.C. Lions |
| WR | Reggie Begelton | Calgary Stampeders |
| WR | Alexander Hollins | B.C. Lions |
| WR | Nic Demski | Winnipeg Blue Bombers |
| OL | Sean McEwen | Calgary Stampeders |
| OL | Patrick Neufeld | Winnipeg Blue Bombers |
| OL | Sukh Chungh | B.C. Lions |
| OL | Jermarcus Hardrick | Winnipeg Blue Bombers |
| OL | Stanley Bryant | Winnipeg Blue Bombers |
| DE | Mathieu Betts | B.C. Lions |
| DE | Willie Jefferson | Winnipeg Blue Bombers |
| DT | Mike Rose | Calgary Stampeders |
| DT | Woody Baron | B.C. Lions |
| LB | Micah Awe | Calgary Stampeders |
| LB | Larry Dean | Saskatchewan Roughriders |
| DB | Emmanuel Rugamba | B.C. Lions |
| DB | Demerio Houston | Winnipeg Blue Bombers |
| DB | Garry Peters | B.C. Lions |
| DB | TJ Lee | B.C. Lions |
| DB | Evan Holm | Winnipeg Blue Bombers |
| DB | Brandon Alexander | Winnipeg Blue Bombers |
| K | Sean Whyte | B.C. Lions |
| P | Adam Korsak | Saskatchewan Roughriders |
| ST | Mario Alford | Saskatchewan Roughriders |
